Skip to content
icemakersale

Home › Guides › Best nugget ice makers

The best nugget ice makers

Nugget ice is soft, chewable and soaks up the flavor of your drink. These are the machines that make it best at home.

By Kevin Marsh. Updated .

Quick answer

The best nugget ice maker is the GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra, rated at 38 pounds a day with a side tank and app control. The Opal Mini packs similar output into a much narrower body. On a budget, the Euhomy 34 lb nugget maker and the Frigidaire Gallery make the same kind of ice for far less money.

Our picks

38lb/day3 lb bin

$400 to $550Nugget

Best overall

GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra

The quietest, most polished nugget ice maker for a countertop. GE rates the Ultra at 1.6 pounds an hour, and the side tank means far fewer refills.

Size
16.5 x 10.5 x 17.5 in (H x W x D)
Extras
WiFi, side tank, scale-inhibiting filter
First batch
About 10 minutes

Good

  • Fastest Opal: rated 1.6 lb of nugget ice per hour
  • Side tank triples the water between refills
  • Quiet, polished and app-connected

Watch for

  • Costs about twice a budget nugget maker
  • Needs weekly cleaning, per GE
Check price on Amazon
36lb/day2 lb bin

$300 to $450Nugget

Best compact nugget maker

GE Profile Opal Mini

Under 9 inches wide and rated at up to 36 pounds a day. The smart choice if counter space is tight.

Size
14.6 x 8.6 x 15.6 in (H x W x D)
Extras
WiFi, filter compatible
First batch
Fast; 1.5 lb per hour rated

Good

  • Opal ice in a body under 9 inches wide
  • Rated up to 36 lb a day
  • Fits under most cabinets

Watch for

  • Smaller bin than the full-size Opal
  • Newer model with less long-term history
Check price on Amazon
44lb/day2.5 lb bin

$230 to $320Nugget

Best high-output budget pick

Frigidaire 44 lb Nugget Ice Maker

The highest rated output from a big-brand budget nugget maker, with a self-clean mode.

Size
Countertop
Extras
Touchscreen, self-clean, transparent window
First batch
Fast

Good

  • Highest rated output among big-brand countertop nugget makers
  • Good for families and parties
  • Self-clean mode

Watch for

  • Larger footprint
  • Costs more than the 33 lb Gallery
Check price on Amazon
34lb/day1.8 lb bin

$130 to $200Nugget

Best value

Euhomy Nugget Ice Maker (34 lb)

Real nugget ice for about a third of the Opal's price.

Size
Compact countertop
Extras
Self-cleaning, carry handle on some versions
First batch
About 6 to 8 minutes

Good

  • Nugget ice at about a third of Opal prices
  • Quick first batch
  • Small enough for apartments and RVs

Watch for

  • Smaller basket
  • Louder and less refined than an Opal
Check price on Amazon
33lb/day2 lb bin

$170 to $250Nugget

Best from a big brand under $250

Frigidaire Gallery Nugget Ice Maker (33 lb)

Touch controls, a clear window and easy in-store returns.

Size
Countertop
Extras
Touchscreen controls, self-clean
First batch
Fast

Good

  • Big-brand nugget maker for less than an Opal
  • Touch controls and a clear window
  • Easy to find in stores

Watch for

  • Bin size is modest
  • Plain styling
Check price on Amazon
35lb/day2.65 lb bin

$120 to $180Nugget

Best narrow budget machine

Kismile Nugget Ice Maker (35 lb)

About 9 inches wide and inexpensive.

Size
About 9 in wide
Extras
Self-cleaning
First batch
Fast

Good

  • Narrow body for tight counters
  • Low price for nugget ice
  • Simple controls

Watch for

  • Basic build
  • Small water tank means frequent refills
Check price on Amazon
44.9lb/day2 lb bin

$150 to $220Nugget

Most output per dollar

Simzlife Nugget Ice Maker

Rated at almost 45 pounds a day for a budget price, though support is thinner than big brands.

Size
Countertop
Extras
Touch screen, self-cleaning
First batch
Fast

Good

  • Very high rated output for the price
  • Touch controls
  • Often discounted

Watch for

  • Lesser-known brand with thinner support
  • Rated output assumes cool room and water
Check price on Amazon

Compare nugget ice makers

Nugget ice makers compared
ModelDaily outputBinPrice bandExtrasPrice
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra38 lb3 lb$400 to $550WiFi, side tank, scale-inhibiting filterCheck price
GE Profile Opal Mini36 lb2 lb$300 to $450WiFi, filter compatibleCheck price
Frigidaire 44 lb Nugget Ice Maker44 lb2.5 lb$230 to $320Touchscreen, self-clean, transparent windowCheck price
Euhomy Nugget Ice Maker (34 lb)34 lb1.8 lb$130 to $200Self-cleaning, carry handle on some versionsCheck price
Frigidaire Gallery Nugget Ice Maker (33 lb)33 lb2 lb$170 to $250Touchscreen controls, self-cleanCheck price
Kismile Nugget Ice Maker (35 lb)35 lb2.65 lb$120 to $180Self-cleaningCheck price
Simzlife Nugget Ice Maker44.9 lb2 lb$150 to $220Touch screen, self-cleaningCheck price

What makes nugget ice different

Nugget ice is made by scraping thin flakes of ice from a chilled cylinder and pressing them together. The result is airy, soft pellets that you can chew easily and that soak up the drink around them. It is the ice served at Sonic and in many hospitals, which is why people also call it Sonic ice or pellet ice. Learn more in our guide to crushed and chewable ice makers.

How to choose

  • Output: 24 to 45 pounds a day covers most households. Output ratings assume cool room and water temperatures.
  • Bin size: most countertop nugget makers hold 2 to 3 pounds. They do not freeze stored ice, so it slowly melts back into the reservoir and gets remade.
  • Water supply: a side tank or larger reservoir means fewer refills.
  • Cleaning: nugget makers need regular cleaning and descaling. GE recommends cleaning the Opal weekly. See how to clean a GE Opal.
  • Noise: premium machines like the Opal are quieter than budget brands.

Questions people ask

What is the best nugget ice maker?

The GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra for most people. On a budget, the Euhomy 34 lb nugget maker or the Frigidaire Gallery.

Is nugget ice the same as Sonic ice?

Yes. Sonic serves nugget ice, so nugget ice makers are often sold as Sonic ice makers.

Do nugget ice makers keep ice frozen?

No. Countertop nugget makers have insulated bins but no freezer. Melted ice drains back and is remade into fresh ice.

How long do nugget ice makers last?

Many last several years with regular cleaning and descaling. Hard water and skipped descaling are the most common causes of failure.

Sources

  1. GE Appliances, Opal nugget ice makers

Read next