Most people searching for an ice maker that crushes ice want soft, chewable crushed ice. Nugget ice makers make exactly that, with no crushing step.
By Kevin Marsh. Updated .
Quick answer
If you want crushed-style chewable ice, buy a nugget ice maker: the GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra is the best, and the Euhomy nugget maker is the best value. Nugget machines make ice from compressed flakes, so it is soft like crushed ice. For true shaved ice for snow cones, you need a shaved ice machine instead.
Crushed ice is broken from cubes. It is sharp-edged and dense.
Nugget ice is made from pressed flakes. It is soft, chewable and looks like crushed ice, but is easier on teeth. This is what most "crushed ice makers" actually make.
Shaved ice is fluffy, snow-like ice shaved from a block, used for snow cones.
Our picks
38lb/day3 lb bin
$400 to $550Nugget
Best overall
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra
The softest, most consistent chewable ice from a countertop machine.
For sharp, cocktail-style crushed ice, freeze cubes and use a manual ice crusher or a blender with an ice-crush setting. A refrigerator with a crushed-ice dispenser also works. For snow cones, look for a shaved ice machine.
Questions people ask
Is there an ice maker that makes crushed ice?
Nugget ice makers make soft, crushed-style ice directly. Refrigerators with crushed-ice dispensers crush cubes on demand.
Is nugget ice the same as crushed ice?
Not quite. Nugget ice is made from compressed flakes and is softer and more chewable than crushed cubes.