Is there a countertop ice maker that keeps ice frozen?
It is the most common question about countertop ice makers. The short answer surprises people.
By Kevin Marsh. Updated .
Quick answer
Almost no countertop ice maker keeps ice frozen. The basket is insulated, not refrigerated, so ice slowly melts and is remade from the melt water. The setups that come closest: a nugget maker like the GE Opal that keeps refilling its bin all day, an undercounter ice maker with a large insulated bin, or any countertop maker plus a freezer bag for storage.
Countertop ice makers do not freeze their baskets. Ice slowly melts back into the reservoir and is remade. Move ice to the freezer if you want to keep it.
Countertop machines have one small cooling system aimed at the freezing plate or auger, not the basket. The melt drains back into the reservoir and becomes new ice, so you rarely run out while it is on.
What comes closest
38lb/day3 lb bin
$400 to $550Nugget
Best always-on nugget ice
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra
Refills its bin continuously, so ice is waiting whenever you want it.