Skip to content
icemakersale

Home › Guides › Keeps ice frozen?

Is there a countertop ice maker that keeps ice frozen?

It is the most common question about countertop ice makers. The short answer surprises people.

By Kevin Marsh. Updated .

Quick answer

Almost no countertop ice maker keeps ice frozen. The basket is insulated, not refrigerated, so ice slowly melts and is remade from the melt water. The setups that come closest: a nugget maker like the GE Opal that keeps refilling its bin all day, an undercounter ice maker with a large insulated bin, or any countertop maker plus a freezer bag for storage.

Why ice melts in a countertop maker

Countertop ice makers do not freeze their baskets. Ice slowly melts back into the reservoir and is remade. Move ice to the freezer if you want to keep it.

Countertop machines have one small cooling system aimed at the freezing plate or auger, not the basket. The melt drains back into the reservoir and becomes new ice, so you rarely run out while it is on.

What comes closest

38lb/day3 lb bin

$400 to $550Nugget

Best always-on nugget ice

GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra

Refills its bin continuously, so ice is waiting whenever you want it.

Size
16.5 x 10.5 x 17.5 in (H x W x D)
Extras
WiFi, side tank, scale-inhibiting filter
First batch
About 10 minutes

Good

  • Fastest Opal: rated 1.6 lb of nugget ice per hour
  • Side tank triples the water between refills
  • Quiet, polished and app-connected

Watch for

  • Costs about twice a budget nugget maker
  • Needs weekly cleaning, per GE
Check price on Amazon
44lb/day2.5 lb bin

$230 to $320Nugget

Most output

Frigidaire 44 lb Nugget Ice Maker

High output keeps the basket topped up.

Size
Countertop
Extras
Touchscreen, self-clean, transparent window
First batch
Fast

Good

  • Highest rated output among big-brand countertop nugget makers
  • Good for families and parties
  • Self-clean mode

Watch for

  • Larger footprint
  • Costs more than the 33 lb Gallery
Check price on Amazon
100lb/day33 lb bin

$400 to $700Clear cubes

Best built-in

Euhomy 100 lb Undercounter Ice Maker

A 33-pound insulated bin holds ice for long stretches.

Size
About 15 in wide
Extras
Freestanding or built-in, ETL listed
Drain
Gravity drain (pump versions available)

Good

  • Huge output for parties and home bars
  • Big 33 lb bin
  • Works built in or freestanding

Watch for

  • Needs a floor drain or a pump version
  • Louder than residential brands
Check price on Amazon
42lb/day22 lb bin

$500 to $800Crescent

Best drainless built-in

COTLIN 15 in Drainless Ice Maker

Big bin and no drain line.

Size
15 in wide
Extras
Drainless design
Drain
None needed

Good

  • No drain line to install
  • Big bin for a drainless unit
  • Fits a standard 15 in opening

Watch for

  • Melt water must be emptied
  • Crescent ice, not nugget
Check price on Amazon

Compare

Ice makers that keep ice ready
ModelIceDaily outputBinPrice bandPrice
GE Profile Opal 2.0 UltraNugget38 lb3 lb$400 to $550Check price
Frigidaire 44 lb Nugget Ice MakerNugget44 lb2.5 lb$230 to $320Check price
Euhomy 100 lb Undercounter Ice MakerClear cubes100 lb33 lb$400 to $700Check price
COTLIN 15 in Drainless Ice MakerCrescent42 lb22 lb$500 to $800Check price

Simple workarounds

  • Run the maker in the morning and bag ice in the freezer.
  • Keep it running during parties; output outpaces melt.
  • Choose nugget ice for chewing; it is meant to be soft.

Questions people ask

Do any portable ice makers keep ice frozen?

Very few. Most countertop and portable ice makers let ice melt back into the reservoir.

How long does ice last in a countertop ice maker?

It starts melting within an hour or two once the machine stops. While running, it keeps replacing what melts.

Read next