Skip to content
icemakersale

Home › Guides › Fridges with ice makers

Choosing a refrigerator with an ice maker

Most fridges with ice makers make the same ice. The differences are where you get it and how much.

By Kevin Marsh. Updated .

Quick answer

For the most convenience, choose a French door or side-by-side refrigerator with a door ice and water dispenser. If you entertain or want specialty ice, look for models with a second ice maker for small or round ice. If you need lots of ice or nugget ice, a countertop or undercounter ice maker beside the fridge does the job better than any fridge.

What to compare

  • Door dispenser or freezer bin: door dispensers are convenient but take shelf space and add parts.
  • Ice types: cubed and crushed are standard; some add specialty ice.
  • Output and storage: fridge ice makers make far less ice per day than dedicated machines.
  • Water filter cost: check the replacement filter price.
  • Repair record: ice makers and dispensers are common service calls on any brand.

When to add a dedicated ice maker

38lb/day3 lb bin

$400 to $550Nugget

For nugget ice

GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra

Soft, chewable ice no fridge matches.

Size
16.5 x 10.5 x 17.5 in (H x W x D)
Extras
WiFi, side tank, scale-inhibiting filter
First batch
About 10 minutes

Good

  • Fastest Opal: rated 1.6 lb of nugget ice per hour
  • Side tank triples the water between refills
  • Quiet, polished and app-connected

Watch for

  • Costs about twice a budget nugget maker
  • Needs weekly cleaning, per GE
Check price on Amazon
100lb/day33 lb bin

$400 to $700Clear cubes

For lots of ice

Euhomy 100 lb Undercounter Ice Maker

Built-in output and a big bin.

Size
About 15 in wide
Extras
Freestanding or built-in, ETL listed
Drain
Gravity drain (pump versions available)

Good

  • Huge output for parties and home bars
  • Big 33 lb bin
  • Works built in or freestanding

Watch for

  • Needs a floor drain or a pump version
  • Louder than residential brands
Check price on Amazon
26lb/day1.5 lb bin

Under $100Bullet

For cheap extra ice

Frigidaire 26 lb Countertop Ice Maker

Quick batches for parties.

Size
About 12 x 11 x 9 in
Extras
Two cube sizes on most versions
First batch
About 7 to 9 minutes

Good

  • Cheap, quick and widely sold
  • Batches of bullet ice in minutes
  • Stainless versions look good on a counter

Watch for

  • Does not keep ice frozen; move it to the freezer
  • Bullet ice melts faster than cubes
Check price on Amazon

Questions people ask

Which refrigerator style makes the most ice?

Fridges vary by model more than style. If you need lots of ice, add a dedicated ice maker.

Read next