Most fridges with ice makers make the same ice. The differences are where you get it and how much.
By Kevin Marsh. Updated .
Quick answer
For the most convenience, choose a French door or side-by-side refrigerator with a door ice and water dispenser. If you entertain or want specialty ice, look for models with a second ice maker for small or round ice. If you need lots of ice or nugget ice, a countertop or undercounter ice maker beside the fridge does the job better than any fridge.
What to compare
Door dispenser or freezer bin: door dispensers are convenient but take shelf space and add parts.
Ice types: cubed and crushed are standard; some add specialty ice.
Output and storage: fridge ice makers make far less ice per day than dedicated machines.
Water filter cost: check the replacement filter price.
Repair record: ice makers and dispensers are common service calls on any brand.